Board-certified dermatologists advise against using makeup wipes as a final step in skincare routines, citing concerns about skin irritation and inadequate cleansing. They also note environmental impacts associated with the products.

Nicole Lee, a board-certified dermatologist and founder of Epoch Dermatology, stated that makeup wipes should be considered a preliminary step, not a complete cleanse. "Think of wipes as a first step, not a final cleanse," Lee said. She explained that the wipes tend to move makeup, oil, and debris across the skin rather than removing it entirely. "They move makeup, oil and debris around rather than remove it," Lee said. She added that the friction from rubbing, the texture of the wipes, and the preservatives and fragrances contained within them can irritate skin. "The combination of friction from rubbing your skin, texture of the wipes and preservatives and fragrances in the wipes can be irritating and lead to inflammation, skin barrier compromise and sensitivity over time," Lee said.

Dr. Nicole Negbenebor, a board-certified dermatologist with UI Health Care, recommended following up makeup wipe use with a cleanser and rinsing to ensure a full facial cleaning. "If you use makeup wipes, it is important to follow up with a cleanser and rinsing to fully clean your face," Negbenebor said. She emphasized that leaving behind residue can prevent complete dirt removal. "You do not want to leave behind the film that can be left from a makeup wipe — that can lead to dirt not being completely removed and potential acne breakouts or irritation," Negbenebor said. Lee suggested that a gentle double cleanse offers a more effective alternative. "A gentle double cleanse is more effective than makeup wipes," Lee said.

For a double cleanse, Lee recommended starting with a cleansing balm or oil, then proceeding with a mild, water-based cleanser. "Start with a cleansing balm or oil, then follow with a mild, water-based cleanser," Lee said. She also shared a method for removing eye makeup, which involves using a gentle lotion on a cotton ball. "A personal trick I have developed over the years is to use a gentle lotion on a cotton ball to remove any residual eye makeup," Lee said. Lee stated this technique cleanses without irritation. "It cleanses without irritation while moisturizing the delicate, easily sensitized skin on the eyelids," Lee said.

Beyond skincare concerns, dermatologists also noted the environmental impact of makeup wipes. Lee said that most wipes are designed for single use and are not biodegradable. "Most wipes are single use and not biodegradable, so they add to waste," Lee said. Disposable makeup wipes are not recyclable and cannot be flushed due to their inability to disintegrate. Lee suggested that reusable cloths used with a quality cleanser offer a more sustainable option. "Reusable cloths with a good cleanser are a more sustainable option," Lee said. Jem Alabi, an editorial operations associate, offered a perspective on alternative products. "This product doesn't sting, leave my skin too dry and red, or have an astringent smell," Alabi said.