Relevance: primary · Type: event
Confidence100%
The Supreme Court issued several major decisions at the end of its term.
Relevance: primary · Type: event
Confidence100%
A Supreme Court decision granted the President the ability to fire the heads of numerous independent agencies.
Relevance: primary · Type: event
Confidence100%
A Supreme Court decision diminished the scope of the Voting Rights Act.
Relevance: primary · Type: event
Confidence100%
A Supreme Court decision granted states the power to ban trans women from sports.
Relevance: primary · Type: event
Confidence100%
A Supreme Court decision granted the executive branch the power to deport hundreds of thousands of immigrants.
Relevance: primary · Type: event
Confidence100%
A Supreme Court decision limited other immigrants’ ability to apply for asylum.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
Several Supreme Court decisions were decided by a 6–3 vote along typical ideological lines.
Relevance: primary · Type: event
Confidence100%
Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Amy Coney Barrett voted with liberal justices in cases where the Trump Administration suffered losses.
Relevance: primary · Type: event
Confidence100%
The Supreme Court issued a decision limiting the President’s power to impose tariffs.
Relevance: primary · Type: event
Confidence100%
The Supreme Court issued a decision blocking the President from ousting Federal Reserve governor Lisa Cook, carving out an exception for the Federal Reserve.
Relevance: primary · Type: event
Confidence100%
The Supreme Court voted to preserve birthright citizenship.
Relevance: primary · Type: event
Confidence100%
Five Justices affirmed birthright citizenship as a Constitutional right.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
Elie Honig is a senior legal analyst at CNN.
Relevance: supporting · Type: action
Confidence100%
Elie Honig wrote a column for New York magazine about the Supreme Court term.
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"The labelling of the Court as political is one of the easiest taglines in our current public discourse."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"Justices Roberts, Barrett, Brett Kavanaugh, and Neil Gorsuch are the only ones who have shown any ability to dispassionately assess the law and—surprisingly often in cases with massive stakes—to reach real-world outcomes that don’t jibe with their own ideology."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"Trump lost some very big cases, and he won some big ones."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"The cases he lost are mostly one-offs, whereas the cases he won will give Donald Trump himself, but also the Presidency more broadly, more power moving forward."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"Both of those policies are now dead and gone, and really, there’s no lasting impact on the executive power of the Presidency, other than you can’t run totally wild with an executive order."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"The tariffs from the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) are [dead and gone]."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"The redistricting case gutted the last remnants of the Voting Rights Act, and opened the door to dissolution of intentionally created majority-Black voting districts."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"This is going to permanently change the way that we redistrict and draw congressional lines, and move power to Republicans in a more systematic way."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"The President’s ability to fire independent agency heads is a structural game changer, because now, the President has complete discretion to fire these quasi-independent agency members for any reason or no reason at all."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"The Supreme Court basically said, ‘To heck with you, Congress, your little law here has no impact.’"
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"The Fed decision does not at all preclude him from firing Lisa Cook."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"It simply says you have to show cause. And you have to go through some sort of process."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"You can’t just fire her by tweet, essentially."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"The win is far, far broader and far more impactful than the loss."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"To hear them tell it in their decisions, it’s because the Fed has a different Constitutional structure."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"It was established directly by Congress."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"I think the real reason, and this is in Kavanaugh’s opinion, is just, as a policy matter, those conservatives and the liberals realize you just don’t want the President messing with the Fed."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"It’s too disruptive to the economy and to international markets."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"If you allow the President to go in and do what he wants with the Fed, now you’re messing with commerce, now you’re messing with international finance, and I think the Justices are wary of that."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"My argument is that the Court is neither entirely political nor that it is entirely apolitical."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"I think what we all basically mean when we say a Justice is being political is that they’re starting from the bottom line."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"They’re starting from the political or policy or real-world outcome, and then reverse-engineering the legal analysis, the math calculation, to give them the desired result."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"I think what we mean when we say that Justices are being nonpolitical is they’re just doing some faithful version of the math equation, and living with the result, whether it aligns with their ideology or not."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"Thomas and Alito, on all the major cases, somehow come to a result that’s pro-Trump or pro-conservative."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"Not once in any major decision this whole term did they reach a decision that gave us a liberal outcome, or that harmed Trump, or that was against the Administration."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"Essentially, the exact opposite applies to the three liberal Justices."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"The only real exception is that they gave a split ruling on the transgender athletes case, where all three liberal Justices agreed with the conservatives that state laws banning transgender athletes comply with Title IX, but dissented on whether it complies with equal protection."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"On a substantial number of very high-stakes cases, we saw two or more of those four Justices reaching results that go against their conservative ideology, that yield nonconservative, anti-Trump, pro-liberal outcomes."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"If all nine Justices just did what I accused the five political Justices of doing, the world would look very different right now."
Elie Honig, CNN senior legal analyst
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"We would have more tariffs in place, and have a substantially narrowed version of birthright citizenship."
forum Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to comment.