Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
Estelle has held permanent resident status in the U.S.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
Estelle is a 57-year-old resident of Lawrence, Kansas
Relevance: primary · Type: event
Confidence90%
On her most recent trip through customs in mid-March, officers detained Estelle for 30 hours
Relevance: primary · Type: event
Confidence90%
Customs officers forced her to spend the night in a holding cell on a concrete slab and threatened her with deportation
Relevance: primary · Type: event
Confidence90%
Customs officers detained Estelle because she acknowledged under questioning that she had voted in a local election despite not being a U.S. citizen
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
A small number of cities in the U.S. allow noncitizens to vote in local elections, but Lawrence, Kansas is not one of them
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
Kansas and federal law require U.S. citizenship to register to vote
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
Historically, U.S. Customs and Border Protection has played no part in election-fraud investigations
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
The transcript of Estelle’s interview shows that CBP had flagged her for special scrutiny and that officers knew her voting history
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
Estelle told a customs officer that she believed she was eligible to vote in local elections because a state motor vehicles department employee had told her so when she renewed her driver’s license
Relevance: primary · Type: event
Confidence90%
A CBP spokesperson confirmed that officers detained a woman matching Estelle’s description at the Detroit airport and placed her in removal proceedings
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
Voting illegally is a deportable offense
spokesperson
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence90%
The CBP spokesperson said, “The Trump Administration will continue to enforce our nation’s laws. Those who violate these laws will be processed, detained, and removed as required.”
Matthew Hoppock, attorney
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
Estelle’s attorney, Matthew Hoppock, said she had no prior criminal history and had not violated the terms of her green card
Relevance: supporting · Type: action
Confidence90%
Estelle registered to vote as part of renewing her driver’s license in 2023
Relevance: supporting · Type: event
Confidence90%
According to Douglas County records, Estelle voted in the November 2023 election, which included races for city council and school boards
Relevance: supporting · Type: event
Confidence90%
Estelle did not vote in any subsequent election, including the 2024 presidential election
Relevance: supporting · Type: event
Confidence90%
An immigration judge granted a request to cancel Estelle’s removal proceedings after her attorney spoke with DHS officials
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
It is unclear whether Estelle will face any future criminal charges
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
CBP declined to comment on whether there are any pending criminal charges against Estelle
Matthew Hoppock, attorney
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence90%
Matthew Hoppock said, “It’s clear as day she wasn’t trying to break the law.”
Kerry Doyle, deputy general counsel for the Department of Homeland Security
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence90%
Kerry Doyle, deputy general counsel for the Department of Homeland Security, said, “It took them a whole lot of energy and effort to sift through all these things to find this needle in the haystack.”
Wendy Weiser, vice president for democracy at the Brennan Center for Justice
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence90%
Wendy Weiser, vice president for democracy at the Brennan Center for Justice, said, “My concern is about the publicizing of these kinds of incidents as a tool to frighten people.”
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
When noncitizen voting cases occur, they are typically identified by local and state election officials who refer them to law enforcement
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
Such cases often do not move forward because the voters were registered by mistake or voted without knowing it was illegal
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
Prosecutors may need to prove that noncitizen voting was intentional depending on the charges
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
President Trump pushed unsuccessfully for Congress to pass the SAVE America Act, which would have required documentary proof of citizenship when registering to vote
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
In March 2025, President Trump issued an executive order directing federal agencies to use their resources to help find and prosecute noncitizen voters
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
The Justice Department demanded that states hand over their voter-roll information
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
The Department of Homeland Security revamped a tool to allow states to check registered voters' citizenship status in bulk
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
The citizenship status verification tool proved highly error-prone
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
The Department of Homeland Security said that Homeland Security Investigations will look into more than 24,000 voters flagged by SAVE as potential noncitizens
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
A former CBP official said that potential noncitizen voters have likely been flagged in the system that customs officers use to check international travelers' records
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence90%
If officers see flags in a traveler’s file, they would question them further on their voting histories
Relevance: supporting · Type: event
Confidence90%
Estelle was detained on a layover while traveling home from visiting her ailing father in France
Relevance: supporting · Type: event
Confidence90%
During her interview, a customs officer asked Estelle if she had registered to vote or voted, and she said she had voted once
Relevance: supporting · Type: event
Confidence90%
The officer asked her if she had voted in the November 7, 2023 local election, and she confirmed that she had
Relevance: supporting · Type: event
Confidence90%
After questioning, officers placed Estelle in a cell with a thin mattress on a concrete slab and gave her a blanket donated by an airline
Relevance: supporting · Type: event
Confidence90%
Estelle was released after more than 30 hours in custody
Jamie Shew, Douglas County clerk
Relevance: supporting · Type: event
Confidence90%
Jamie Shew, the Douglas County clerk, said he received an administrative subpoena from CBP on March 23 requesting Estelle’s voter registration application and voting records
forum Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to comment.