Relevance: primary · Type: event
Confidence100%
Lee Berger led a team of anthropologists that unearthed the remains of more than 20 small-bodied hominins from the Rising Star Cave System in South Africa in 2013.
Relevance: primary · Type: background
Confidence100%
The Homo naledi remains unearthed in the Rising Star Cave System are between 335,000 and 236,000 years old.
Relevance: primary · Type: event
Confidence100%
Palesa Madupe, a molecular scientist at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology, and colleagues analyzed proteins in dental enamel from 23 Homo naledi teeth.
Relevance: primary · Type: background
Confidence100%
The 23 teeth analyzed came from at least 20 different individuals ranging from infants to older adults.
Relevance: primary · Type: event
Confidence100%
All 23 tooth samples contained the protein amelogenin-X (AMELX), which is encoded on the X-chromosome.
Relevance: primary · Type: event
Confidence100%
None of the 23 tooth samples contained the protein AMELY, which is encoded on the Y-chromosome and typically present in genetically male humans.
Palesa Madupe, molecular scientist
Relevance: primary · Type: quote
Confidence100%
Palesa Madupe and colleagues stated that given the level of AMELX in the samples, they should have been able to detect AMELY if it were present.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
The probability of all sampled individuals being female by chance is approximately 0.0000954 percent, according to Palesa Madupe and colleagues.
Relevance: primary · Type: background
Confidence100%
Every known Homo naledi skeleton for which teeth were available in the Rising Star Cave System is genetically female.
Relevance: supporting · Type: event
Confidence100%
The study was published in the journal Cell on June 24, 2025.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
Lee Berger is a National Geographic explorer-in-residence.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
John Hawks is a paleoanthropologist at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
Enrico Cappellini is a paleoproteomics researcher at the University of Copenhagen.
Relevance: supporting · Type: event
Confidence100%
Five of the 20 Homo naledi individuals in the study share a protein variant with Paranthropus robustus.
Relevance: supporting · Type: event
Confidence100%
Fifteen of the Homo naledi teeth analyzed contained a protein version apparently unique to Homo naledi.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
Paranthropus robustus lived in South Africa between 1 million and 2 million years ago.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
Lee Berger co-authored the recent study on Homo naledi proteins.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
John Hawks co-authored the recent study on Homo naledi proteins.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
Enrico Cappellini co-authored the recent study on Homo naledi proteins.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
Elizabeth Sawchuk is the curator of human evolution at the Cleveland Museum of Natural History.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
Elizabeth Sawchuk was not involved in the study.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
The skeleton known as Neo was originally assumed to be male.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
The skeleton known as DH1 was originally assumed to be male.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
Proteomic analysis is a technique that sequences genetic material from ancient proteins.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
The AMELX gene variant is found in both males and females.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
The AMELY gene variant is found only in biological males.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
Homo naledi has a brain size comparable to that of a chimpanzee.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
Homo naledi facial, hand, and leg structures resemble those of modern humans and recent hominins.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
Homo naledi torso structures resemble those of apes and Australopithecines.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
DNA in Homo naledi bones from the Rising Star Cave System had degraded too much for sequencing attempts a decade ago.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
South Africa's heat causes DNA to break down faster than in regions where Neanderthal and Denisovan remains were found.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
Proteins can last longer than DNA in fossilized remains.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
A deletion of the AMELY gene has occurred in at least one Neanderthal.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
Chimpanzees and gorillas live in groups where nearly all adults are female, but these groups include children of both sexes.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
The Rising Star team suggested in 2023 that Homo naledi may have used fire in the cave.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
The Rising Star team advanced the claim in 2025 that Homo naledi buried their dead.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
Dentin contains more proteins than enamel.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
Sampling dentin requires cutting deeper into fossil teeth than sampling enamel.
Relevance: supporting · Type: background
Confidence100%
The teeth analyzed were unearthed from four different cave chambers in the Rising Star system.
Lee Berger, National Geographic explorer-in-residence
Relevance: primary · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"This was no longer chance, at this point."
John Hawks, paleoanthropologist
Relevance: primary · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"It is rarely the case that we have such clear evidence of culture as this case is."
John Hawks, paleoanthropologist
Relevance: primary · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"It’s like, there is no other process that can make this happen."
Enrico Cappellini, paleoproteomics researcher
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"That’s the aspiration, to start to have molecular evidence that is rich enough to be informative for reconstruction of early hominin evolution in Africa and outside Africa."
Enrico Cappellini, paleoproteomics researcher
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"For now, we wanted to deliver these results and see the feedback from the scientific community."
Enrico Cappellini, paleoproteomics researcher
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"Based on that, we will continue with further analysis."
Lee Berger, National Geographic explorer-in-residence
Relevance: primary · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"I think it is fair to say that they surprised us."
Lee Berger, National Geographic explorer-in-residence
Relevance: primary · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"H. naledi has always been an enigmatic discovery."
Lee Berger, National Geographic explorer-in-residence
Relevance: primary · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"The most likely reason for these robust results are, in my opinion, cultural selection after death for burial by sex and perhaps gender."
John Hawks, paleoanthropologist
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"There are many past human societies with sex-specific burial practices."
John Hawks, paleoanthropologist
Relevance: primary · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"The H. naledi skeletons are older than any known Neanderthal or modern human burial site, and it's remarkable to see that they may all be female."
Elizabeth Sawchuk, curator of human evolution
Relevance: primary · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"The bottom line is this is a weird result from an already weird hominin."
Elizabeth Sawchuk, curator of human evolution
Relevance: primary · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"The key thing to remember is that failure to detect evidence of AMELY does not mean there are no males in the sample — it just means that none were detected."
Enrico Cappellini, paleoproteomics researcher
Relevance: primary · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"It is very unlikely that this would be the case among even half of the 20 individuals we studied or for an entire population."
Enrico Cappellini, paleoproteomics researcher
Relevance: primary · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"Either scenario, namely the absence of H. naledi males in the Rising Star cave system or a systematic deletion of their AMELY gene, is fascinating and would have deep implications for a better understanding of the biology and evolution of this species."
Elizabeth Sawchuk, curator of human evolution
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"Studies of H. naledi, a species known from a single site, continue to yield more questions than answers."
Elizabeth Sawchuk, curator of human evolution
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"As the authors point out, this is a surprising result that requires more investigation."
John Hawks, paleoanthropologist
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"We are assessing whether it’s now promising to do DNA sampling, and I am hopeful."
John Hawks, paleoanthropologist
Relevance: supporting · Type: quote
Confidence100%
"I can’t yet predict what outcome we might get."
forum Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to comment.